Where’s Your Golden Compass?
Friday, November 30th, 2007
Libraries may be missing potential circulation from a 12-year-old title. The movie of The Golden Compass is due to hit US theaters on Dec. 7 (it premiered in London last week). In the US, it’s already received marketing help from the American Catholic League. The group has urged fellow Catholics to boycott the movie and not read the book, adding the allure of forbidden fruit.
Due to the book’s age and this sudden attention, libraries may find they don’t have enough copies of Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy which is now #9 on Amazon’s bestseller list. The trilogy and the individual titles are also on the USA Today bestseller list. A quick look at several library catalogs reveals that most copies are in circulation, with holds against them. In one instance, a large library system no longer has any copies of the 12-year-old first title in the series and holds are building on the audio version.
And don’t look only on The Golden Compass. Once the movie hits, fans will likely be interested in the other two volumes in the trilogy, The Subtle Knife and The Amber Spy Glass to find out “what happens next.”
With the controversy in the news, this would also be a good time to pull out and display the many books of critical essays on the trilogy.
In talking to customers about the controversy, you may want to point them to an article in this week’s Newsweek which puts it this way — “The loud, bristling organization known as the Catholic League is urging families to boycott a film in which the word ‘Catholic’ is never uttered.”
For those unfamiliar with the American Catholic League, Wikipedia offers an overview. It points out that the League has many critics among Catholics and that the organization’s own estimate of the number of members is a modest 330,000. An article in the New York Times from 1999 questions how much the organization represents Catholics, but also says, under Donohue, it has become “one of the most visible defenders of the Roman Catholic Church.”
The Catholic League does not speak for the Catholic Church. An article from the Associated Press notes that the “U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Office for Film and Broadcasting gave the film, which is rated PG-13, a warm review. The film is not blatantly anti-Catholic but a ‘generalized rejection of authoritarianism,’ it said.”
The only report so far of the book being challenged comes from the Toronto Star. An Ontario Catholic school board had the trilogy removed from the libraries in its 37 schools for evaluation. While the the books are being evaluated, the they are not on display, but students can request them. The article notes that “Catholic schools in Toronto and York Region have the books on their shelves and report no complaints.”


